Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Kara Neidel
REALTOR®, Lic. Real Estate Salesperson
(716) 574-6339
Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Zillow Icon Twitter Icon 

Customer Reviews

Submit a Review
  • 5 stars
    12
  • 4 stars
    0
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

Kara Neidel
(12 ratings)
5 out of 5 based on 12 ratings.
12 user reviews.
testimonial quote

I would recommend Kara to anyone looking to buy or sell. As first-time homebuyers, we had a lot of questions, and she guided us through every step of the process while always making us feel heard and supported. She truly pays attention to the details and follows through on everything she says she’ll do, which is rare to find. We felt confident and taken care of the entire time. I can’t recommend Kara enough!

Jessica McConville | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

We had an excellent experience working with Kara Neidel to both sell our home and purchase a new one. She took extra care to understand and work with the specific financing options we wanted, which made the entire process much smoother and less stressful. Kara showed us many homes and was patient, attentive, and never rushed us. Her follow-through was outstanding, and she consistently paid close attention to every detail from start to finish. We always felt informed and supported. We would highly recommend Kara to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, dedicated, and detail-oriented realtor.

Melissa Martin
testimonial quote

Kara was excellent from start to finish!! Professional yet personable. We purchased a home with her and then sold a home with her. With her attention to detail, experience in the field, and excellent work ethic she made both transactions much less stressful than they could have been despite the many obstacles we encountered. If you are looking to buy or to sell I highly recommend Kara!!

Robin McConville | Home Seller & Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kara made buying a home even in today's real estate market as painless as possible, and her kindness and professionalism paid off for us. When the original buyer of the home we originally wanted fell through, the sellers chose Kara and our offer solely because Kara was a better realtor who had treated them with more respect and kindness than the multiple other realtors who made a similar offer as we did. She answered my many questions in great detail, answered me during all hours of the day, and most importantly, was honest. All this was also done at the beginning of a pandemic no less.

Trevor Wrona | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

I recently had the pleasure of working with Kara to sell my home. She came highly recommended and didn't disappoint. Kara is knowledgable, supportive and patient with all our questions. She was there for us throughout the process and we offers the first weekend the house was shown. We closed 2 months later and couldn't be happier with the outcome. Buying and selling a home is stressful and Kara was wonderful to work with. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy/sell. Thanks Kara!

CYNTHIA BUKOSKEY | Home Seller
testimonial quote

As a small business owner, I appreciate customer service and attention to detail. Kara Neidel NAILED it for my family !!! Not only did she sell my husbands home in under a week, she found our perfect forever home for our big family of 7. Her honesty, her expertise, her knowledge of real estate and her ability to make the whole buying/selling a home process as stress~free as possible was incredible!! Please be sure to reach out to her because #rockstarrealtor should be her personal hashtag!!! Shannon Connors CEO/ Owner Shannon Connors Fitness Mom of 5 Elementary Education teacher

Shannon Connors ~ Hershey | Home Seller & Home Buyer
testimonial quote

I have had the pleasure of Kara’s services with buying and selling. The personal and outstanding service that Kara provides is second to none. She goes above and beyond. She was just a phone call or text away and was prompt at answering all of my questions. I would not consider anyone else to help me navigate through the the process of buying or selling a home. She was very knowledgeable and on top of everything during the process. Thank you Kara, you’re the best!!!!!!

Rachel DeStefano | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

After renting for two years, my daughter was looking to buy her first home and Kara with her expertise made it happen. We looked at 30 or so homes and bid on several without success. Yet Kara with her encouragement to be patient, persistence, honesty and incredible knowledge finally made this come to fruition. My daughter bought an awesome house which she loves. Kara made the entire process smooth and seamless. Thank you Kara for ALL you did. I highly recommend Kara.

Trish Tworek | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Professional, resourceful, knowledgable! Kara worked with me for months prior to listing my house for sale. She was with me every step of the way through the home selling process and really helped to relieve my anxiety. When I ended up being out of the country during the closing, Kara handled all of the details for me. Highly recommend Kara!

Maureen Geary | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Kara sold my house in Lancaster for more than we originally asked, and did so with urgency and efficiency! Kara’s people skills are 2nd to none, and I’m not sure that I know anyone that doesn’t like her! She has a keen understanding of the marketplace and is exceptionally well connected in the community! If you want the best, hire her to sell your house or find a house for you!

Bruce Saunders | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Loved working with Kara on both ends, selling and buying. She fought for us to get the house we wanted for the price we needed. She was always with us when we had to go to the house we were buying after our offer was accepted, making sure everything was in order. I would recommend Kara with highest honors to anyone “You won’t be sorry for picking her”

Bernie Wyzykowski | Home Seller & Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Reliable and knowledgeable, that’s how I would describe Kara. She will find you the right house and won’t settle for less. It is a tough market for buying right now, but you wouldn’t know that when you have her on your side. The process felt effortless. She is well connected and knows when to hold ‘em and knows when to fold ‘em. You want her in your corner. I am a happy home owner. Thanks Kara.

Lahneen Black | Home Buyer

Share Your Experience

The experience you've had in working with me is important. Please take a few moments and share how your experience was so I can share it with others.

Review Submission Form
  • Markets:
  • 1 Stars2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 04/18/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 04/18/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Sat 04/18/2026 3:53:06 PM EST) or New York State Alliance MLS (last updated Sat 04/18/2026 3:51:25 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than MJ Peterson Real Estate may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel